In the world of anime,NarutoandOne Piecestand as two powerhouse Shonen series. While the two have different stories and unique characters, They both have protagonists with lofty ambitions who draw fans in with their charisma and charm.
WhileOne Piecefocuses on Monkey D, Luffy’s quest to become the Pirate King,Narutoinstead follows Naruto Uzumaki’s journey to become the Hokage of Konoha Village. While the two share completely different settings and narratives, there are comparisons to be made between the two. So which series comes out on top when you do?
RELATED:One Piece: Jewelry Bonney And Kuma’s Connection, Explained
Plot &Theme
The beginning of One Piece is insouciant in nature; in fact, a bit of mundanity arrests the mind. But delving more into the journey of Luffy, when he recruited scaredy-cat Usopp, the hero’s choice seems questioning. Why choose an unduly fearful man into his crew for such a dangerous voyage? Will this dumb and trustful Luffy get to be the ruler of the sea? Now, Oda made Luffy central to the plot, but at the same time, more characters take center stage with him.
In other words,Luffy isn’t the only character to root for in the show; Roronoa Zoro, Trafalgar D. Law, Oden, Whitebeard, Ace and many others. The many mysteries Oda throws consistently amidst the tumultuous plot make the long-running episodes that have yet to meet its finale a worthwhile series to jump on. There is no end to the mysteries— what happened in the 800 years void? Does it have something to do with the mysterious Imu? What is so unique to the government about Vivi? What could the one Piece be? and many others. For One Piece, fans can’t easily envisage its direction. Fans make assumptions made to match and give meaning to the puzzling questions Oda raised in the series. However, every journey must have an end; it is to wait for Oda to reveal answers to these mysteries in the final arc.
Naruto is an emotionally intense anime series. This is evident right from the beginning young lonely, and troublesome Naruto is introduced. He is a young boy who dealt with life at such a young age that troublemaking is the only way he feels like a part of the community that despises him. Naruto portrays a more severe and acute somberness than One Piece. For One Piece, it is primarily a combination of lightheartedness and grittiness. Naruto is more direct in its plot introduction; it immediately sets a more mature ambience without straddling the fence. Unlike One Piece, which wavers so much in the beginning, the tone and mood it aims to go for aren’t set till later in the show. The story and massacre of the Uchiha clan how confused and moulded young Sasuke’s views throughout his life. Kishimoto uses the many tragedies in the series to overburden the characters and thus drive the plot.
One Piece and Naruto both establish similar elements like; friendship, hope, believing in oneself, effects of war, discrimination, and most importantly, not giving up on one’s dream. For fans who enjoy both shows, these familiar essentials are enough to hold the fort to withstand the unfinished adventure of One Piece.
Characters
One Piece holds true to its array of diverse characters. Not only are these characters memorable, but they are also humorous. Oda recognized the need for humor to reduce tension in the long series. Naruto has intense character development, even better thanOne Piece.
While both remain true to having unforgettable characters, Naruto’s characters have more depth than One Piece. Almost all the main characters in Naruto are bestowed different tragedies and burdens they carry till the end of the show to strengthen their bond with the viewers. It is relatively easy to be more invested in Naruto’s characters due to the small size of its characters; however, One Piece has so many characters with respect to the genre of story and events it wants to unfold.
RELATED:Sasuke Retsuden Chapter 4: What To Expect
Naruto has the typical trope of avillainy group named the Akatsuki, a common trope in most anime. As expected, this group incites events that lead to a great war which permeates almost the entire series. Moreover, in One Piece, there is a ‘power up’ factor. Fans are shown so many villains that they visualize what power and problems the next villain will come with. Likewise, Oda doesn’t just make the villains forgettable as the Straw Hat pirates face them in different story arcs.
They all contribute immensely to the significant parts of the story in the long run. This is the craft and ingenuity of Oda, how he makes different threads of unrelated characters and events have due relevance to the story. World Building
Worldbuilding
In anime, what allures fans are the spectacular invented worlds the creators use to captivate fans. It is these fantastical worlds that most times convey the thematic values and believability of animes. In Naruto, there is the Shinobi nation which seems restrained and unexplored. There is also the constant need to keep tilting the odds in the protagonist’s favor— there aren’t many limitations.
However, One Piece’s adventure is unending, with various races (Fishman, Celestial Dragons etc.), oceans, and islands. The world Oda created is an escapade that, once it is ventured in, there is no turning back. Oda made it more realistic by making a world with too many mysteries and possibilities like the real world.
Original Soundtrack
While One Piece has a great soundtrack, Naruto’s is far more distinct and fascinating. Naruto has many more osts than One Piece and is far more memorable. Naruto’s Blue Bird soundtrack has to be one of the greatest soundtracks in anime. One Piece’s “Bings Sake” also strikes a chord that reels fans to cheer on Luffy’s adventure. These soundtracks are the heart and soul of anime. They are just as important as other elements in anime; they add intensity to events and characters' actions.
The idea of finding the best between Naruto and One Piece will never be balanced. They are both great masterpieces by two brilliant creators, and while it will always divide anime fans, picking one over the other depends on a fan’s opinion and perspective. However, it is great to just enjoy the two shows.
